Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 June 1996
- 1. (The question itself is not contained in the recording; from the answer it appears it concerned differences of opinion (ikhtilaf) in the Ummah, their causes and consequences.)
- 2. The question is from Captain Asaf Ahmad of Mardan [the one with the beard who attended the last Urdu session]: Is the coming of Hazrat Messiah (as) and Hazrat Mahdi (as) mentioned in the Holy Qur’an? You explained this in the light of the Hadith in the last Urdu question-and-answer session; he wants to know whether it is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an or not.
- 3. Mr. Mushtaq from Hayes, Middlesex. He has the question in English and translates it into Urdu on request. It concerns the book “Ek Ghalati ka Izala” (Removal of a Misunderstanding) by Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as). He says it states that all doors of prophethood are closed except that of Sirat-us-Siddiq, and further that Hazrat Mirza Sahib said: “I have never denied prophethood,” and that messengership exists only in the sense that “I have no law (Shari’a).” He asks how these statements fit together and whether there is not a contradiction. He also mentions that “Khatam-e-Nubuwwat” is a sign of Buruz and that through the characters “Muhammad and Ahmad” (Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya) he was understood as a kind of Zilli (shadow) prophet.
- 4. Mr. (Masood?) Hussain from the Newham Jamaat: I had two questions; I have already partly received the answer to one. My second question concerns the prophecy about the Imam Mahdi that he will break the cross and eliminate the swine. To what extent did Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) achieve success in this?
- 5. Question from Mr. Malik from Kirkcaldy (North-West/-East?), who lived in Bahrain for a long time: Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib wrote in his early books that Hazrat Jesus (as) was raised to heaven; later he believed that he had died and that Mirza Sahib himself was the Promised Messiah. Please explain this contradiction.
- 6. Question from Ms. Tahira Younis from Clapham, a non-Ahmadi lady (present): Why are Ahmadis not accepted as Muslims? If Ahmadis are Muslims, how can I know that they are Muslims?
- 7. Mr. Syed Irshad Ali Bukhari: Respected Mirza Sahib, earlier attendees said that the funds of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat run through the cooperation of its members. Please explain in detail whether these funds, Masha’Allah, are so large that they cover everything. Second: what conditions apply for a new member who comes to you, and what can he do? Third – forgive the impertinence, I am no scholar, just a humble man: in the Holy Qur’an Allah mentions jinn and humans; there is no mention of any Muslim or sect; in my view being human is the highest. (Huzur interjects: when you declare that the Holy Qur’an mentions jinn and humans but not Muslims, that is not right.) He continues: whoever acts on the Holy Qur’an goes its way; there deeds count, no one asks your lineage. What are you doing to cooperate with Pakistan, with the Pakistani government – we have to sit together and solve the problem? The Holy Prophet (saw) went to inquire after the woman who threw rubbish at him; are our hearts so torn that we invoke his footsteps yet avoid them? Please answer in detail, in simple words, without quoting Hadith.
- 8. (The question is not contained in the recording; the transcript begins in the middle of the answer.)
- 9. (Fragmentary:) … Ever since you … on this, have you tried how this … whoever wants, we … [In substance: Why does the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat not cooperate with Pakistan or strive for the unity of the Ummah?]
- 10. This question comes from the ladies' hall, from Anjum Rashid of Greenford. She writes: Hudhur, I have recently become an Ahmadi, because of which my family is angry with me. In their anger my elder brother said: You … [gap] … not their child. I …, by which my mother too was hurt. My question is only: Have I in this way disobeyed my parents or not? Because the Holy Prophet (saw) … May Hudhur kindly elaborate.
10 of 10 left today