Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 May 1997
- 1. Sir, I would like to submit something. These brothers are also sitting here; if I say something wrong, please do not take offence, I speak according to my knowledge. The Tabligh of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is moving ahead more and more in Europe. But why are these people coming from Pakistan? The Ahmadis should face the opposition in Pakistan.
- 2. Sir, I would like to make a small submission – no offence, since we are talking one should speak, so the heart is reassured. When a Mubahala takes place and prayers are made, the punishment should not fall on these poor people, but on those who tell lies and lead people astray.
- 3. But sir, why are the media, the newspapers etc., silent on this matter?
- 4. Sir, this should come in your broadcasts: that the Mubahala took place there at the Ka‘bah and afterwards this was the result.
- 5. I have two questions. The first concerns the Mubahala, or rather this: it is a rule of the Holy Qur’an that Jews and Christians cannot be your friends, rather they are friends of one another, and whoever among you befriends them is not of us. An author has written a book in England which I read. Further: the political asylum that Ahmadis get in Europe, mainly from Pakistan. The objection raised is that the British in particular, and Europe in general, support Ahmadiyyat directly and indirectly.
- 6. But sir, one thing: what Huzoor says is allegorical, symbolic. It is also said of the miracles of Christ that they were symbolic, that in the true sense they did not happen. And then it is said of the Dajjal that he too is not a character in the true sense, but symbolic.
- 7. (Continuation of an answer; the corresponding question precedes this excerpt. From the context it concerns the belief that Jesus (as) ascended bodily to heaven, travels in space and will return, and whether God breaks His own laws of nature for this.)
- 8. (Name: Khalid, non-Ahmadi, from Sialkot, here for ten years.) My question to you is: Mirza Sahib made his claim step by step, right? I don't have much knowledge, but as I have heard, first he claimed … [Hazrat: Imam Mahdi.] … Imam Mahdi, then so on. I don't have much knowledge, I am just telling you what I have heard.
- 9. (Non-Ahmadi) The brother mentioned earlier that you had spoken of Hazrat Jesus' (as) journey at the speed of light, that he will only be coming back after so many billions of years. So I want to ask: in your view, is the event of the Night of Mi'raj false?
- 10. In contrast, one more question: so you say the Holy Prophet (saw) did not travel physically but it was spiritual, a vision. In contrast there is another miracle of the Holy Prophet (saw), that he with his hand split the moon … [Hazrat: That is quite correct.] Was Allah's system, the law of God, not disrupted by it? The reason is that this was the power of a prophet's finger, i.e. of God. (Interjections: By your logic God is subject to the system of science? Science says man came into being millions of years ago, e.g. Louis Pasteur … How then did Allah create Hazrat Adam (as)? Later: one more question.)
- 11. May I ask a question, one more: what is your position in this Jamaat? Are you a mullah, a scholar, a prophet? (Follow-up: law-bearing and non-law-bearing …)
- 12. I have another question: it has come in the hadith that the Khilafat after the Holy Prophet would last thirty years. [Hazrat: Does it come in the hadith? It did not last that long.] Yes, it came in the hadith that it will last thirty years. … And how long will this Khilafat of yours last?
- 13. (After the closing remarks:) Among you too there are people in the mosque who teach children for their betterment in Islam – are they also called mullahs? Do you hate mullahs so much? Mullahs lead the prayer. (Further: The mullah I studied with was a very pious man; I have no prejudice against you. And what do you call the preachers in your mosques who lead the prayer – are they not mullahs?)
10 of 10 left today