Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 March 1987
- 1. A few days ago Mansur and I were sitting in Bukhari Sahib’s house, and there he raised a question: that Mirza Sahib had written a letter to Queen Victoria, which is printed, in which he asked for some help.
- 2. Hazrat, my master, every Ahmadi and every Muslim wishes to see the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and at least in a dream to have the opportunity to sit in his company. How should one pray to fulfil this wish?
- 3. In the interview Huzur gave to the radio in Keynote, in reply to a question about the Crusades in the time of Hazrat Salahuddin Ayyubi etc., you said there was no time to go into detail. In my view it was part of jihad; although territorial rights were involved, I considered it a kind of jihad, because the Muslims, for Bait-ul-Maqdis … – What did I say in the interview? – You said that a wrong impression could arise from it.
- 4. Huzur, the clerics in Iran permit mut‘ah (temporary marriage) and prove that it is permissible. – Has it been proven to you? – No, not to me. – Why then do you say ‘prove’? – They try to prove it. These people say that Hazrat Ali declared it permissible, although it had been prohibited before; in Islam at one time it was probably also permitted, then it was prohibited. If mut‘ah were declared permissible today, what form would it take in Islamic society?
- 5. There's one thing I don't exactly understand so much about, that's the black stone. I don't know if you know that. There are very simple explanations on it, but I'd like to know more about this. (When asked what concerns him:) I read that this stone came down from heaven or something like that, and it is in Mecca, but that is all I know.
- 6. Hudhur, when government and religion come together in a place, the difference between them becomes so small, and power lies in the hands of the government – what form can religion then take, what situation can arise, and how can religion remain in its original state, separate from government?
- 7. Assalamu alaikum, Hudhur. A few days ago, a friend mentioned the following question in the presence of other friends. I too expressed my opinion on this matter, but since I do not have much knowledge about it, I respectfully request Hudhur to benefit us with your blessed words. Further, I should mention that after writing this question I learnt that it has been asked before. If Hudhur permits, I will read the question. The question is: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that if a person falls ill, the suffering he undergoes because of the illness causes his sins to be forgiven. It is observed that small children sometimes face severe illnesses. Since small children are sinless, the question is why they have to face such illnesses, and which of their sins are forgiven as a result of the illnesses?
- 8. Another question: a few days ago, after a meeting of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in Cambridge, a friend mentioned that since Ahmadi Muslims believe that the second descent of Jesus (as) upon the white minaret does not mean literally descending upon a minaret, the question is asked: if Jesus (as) was not to descend upon a minaret, why then did the Promised Messiah (as) have the Minarat-ul-Masih built in Qadian? Hudhur, kindly guide us on this subject.
- 9. Hudhur, a question has been received from the ladies. They write: the subject of the existence of God the Exalted is very important and vast, but if there is an occasion when an atheist is to be introduced in five or ten minutes to some proof of the existence of God, which proof should be given first and how should it be presented?
- 10. Assalamu alaikum. I am asking a question on behalf of a friend; due to reserve he does not ask himself. … The question is: he read in a children's book on Islamic studies that after the Holy Prophet (saw), Moses (as) is mentioned the most. I do not know whether this is a fact or not, but Moses (as) is mentioned very frequently. Is there a particular reason for this?
- 11. Hudhur, a short question: some people offer the Nawafil sitting after the prayer. To what extent is this correct? … One case is that a person is ill and cannot pray standing, but some people are fit and healthy and offer Nawafil sitting after the prayer; there are Ahmadi friends too. … Hudhur, the Fard they offer standing, the Sunnah too they offer standing, but the Nawafil they offer sitting.
- 12. Hudhur, Zakat is mentioned a great deal in the Holy Qur’an. Please shed some light on its philosophy: on which things is Zakat obligatory, who are entitled to it, to whom should it be given, and can Ahmadis give this Zakat through the channels of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, or can it also be given through other channels? … My knowledge about it is limited. … Hudhur, are those whose salaries are taxed also obliged? … On what is it levied, for example on salary or on jewellery?
10 of 10 left today