Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 December 1991
- 1. I belong to [unclear: Pattoki]. Huzoor, a Hadith says that the Promised Messiah will descend near or upon a white minaret. When the Promised Messiah, our beloved master, came, he built this minaret. What is the purpose of this?
- 2. My second question: We say that if someone enters the Khilafat of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, takes Bai’at at the hand of the Khalifa of the time and then becomes an apostate, we call him an apostate. Why then are those who did not take Bai’at at the hand of the [fourth] Khalifa of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), Hazrat Ali (ra), but even fought against him, not called apostates?
- 3. Master Nazir Ahmad from [unclear], Kamalia. Yesterday I met a friend from Jammu and Kashmir. He told how Ahmadiyyat came into his family: one of their elders prepared for Hajj, and when he reached Amritsar he learned that the route to Hajj was closed. He had previously heard a prophecy that when the Imam Mahdi comes and makes his claim, the route to Hajj will be closed. So he said: Tell me, where is the Imam Mahdi, if the Hajj route is closed? People told him that a man in Qadian is making the claim. My question: is there any mention of or hint at this in the Holy Qur’an or Hadith?
- 4. My name is Razzaq Mahmood Tahir, I have the opportunity to serve as Nazim Irshad in the Sargodha area, grandson of the former Darwesh Master Sharif Ahmad Sahib. When Pharaoh called the sorcerers and they threw their ropes, the ropes became snakes …
- 5. [Question inaudible; apparently about the meaning of ‘Qalb’ (heart) in the Holy Qur’an, since thinking takes place in the brain.]
- 6. My name is Basharat Ahmad Kausar, [Mu’allim, place unclear]. Huzoor, I have three questions. First: Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) wrote in Tafsir-e-Saghir on Surah Yusuf that when Hazrat Yusuf (as) sent a message to his father, he sent his shirt as a token, and it was the shirt he was wearing when he left home. He also gave the example of Ayaz, who had kept his clothes. But the Holy Qur’an says that his brothers had taken off the shirt he wore from home and taken it away. How does this fit?
- 7. Second question: There is a Hadith of the Holy Prophet (saw) that my Ummah will split into 73 sects; 72 will go to hell, one to paradise. What is meant by the sect that goes to paradise? [Huzoor: He said ‘Jamaat’, do not alter the Hadith.] All right, one Jamaat. We say we are that Jamaat. But in our Jamaat there are some people whose deeds appear such that they do not deserve paradise.
- 8. Huzoor, my name is Mirza Akhtar Baig, District Kasur, [place unclear] is my village. Hazrat Ali (ra) moved the capital of the Khilafat from Medina to Kufa. Why did he move it, and were those reasons fulfilled? If they were fulfilled in his lifetime, why did he not return to Medina? Did Hazrat Ali (ra) make any statement about it?
- 9. [Question inaudible; presumably about adopting Western values/culture.]
- 10. [Question inaudible.]
- 11. [Question inaudible; apparently about an incident in which a pious man refused alms to a woman who frightened him with dreams.]
- 12. [A lady’s question inaudible; apparently whether, according to the Holy Qur’an, there are other inhabited worlds besides the earth.]
- 13. [The third lady’s question inaudible; apparently whether one should stand up when, in gatherings of other Muslims, everyone stands at the mention of the Holy Prophet’s (saw) name, although they do not know their own religion.]
- 15. Assalamu alaikum. My name is Abdul Wadud. I belong to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat Soro in Odisha. My question is: when our non-Ahmadi brothers there face some hardship or have some need, for example when their children sit an exam to pass their education, they go to their Pir and say: “When our child passes, we will lay a sheet at the Pir’s shrine.” Or if someone falls ill or has an accident, they lay sheets on graves. They make a vow to the Baba: when he recovers, we will lay a sheet on the Baba’s grave. (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh): All right, so what is your question?) My question: when someone then recovers or the child passes – this practice is obviously completely wrong, it is polytheistic; it is God who does it, yet they keep clothing the Pir with sheets. And then – does the grave feel cold that they cover it with cloth?
- 16. Assalamu alaikum. My name is Qamar Alam, I have come from Calcutta. In the area where we live there is a Muslim population of four to five hundred thousand. There were only two Ahmadi households there. The Muslims once attacked both houses, and one family apostatised; only our family is left. To do Tabligh to these people we need to be friends with them. When they give us halwa etc. at their festivals, such as Shab-e-Barat, should we accept it or not?
- 17. Assalamu alaikum. My name is Raja Abdus Sami. I have come from Abu Dhabi to attend the Jalsa. Huzoor, my question is: regarding the letters which Hazrat Masih-e-Mau‘ud (as) wrote to the Queen, the Empress of India – a non-Ahmadi friend of mine, who was receiving Tabligh and was very impressed, obtained these books from somewhere, from a non-Ahmadi Maulvi. (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh): They are not hidden; we have printed them ourselves, it is no secret.) Yes. After that he raised the objection that Hazrat Masih-e-Mau‘ud (as), in order to attract the Queen’s attention, adopted an extremely submissive manner and assured her of his loyalty at many places. (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh): I have already given a detailed answer to this question in the addresses I delivered in reply to the objections propagated by the Government of Pakistan. Have you not heard them?) I have heard them. (Then you have the full answer.) His actual question was whether you could present an example showing that before this too some appointed one of his age wrote such letters to a ruler or adopted such a humble manner.
10 of 10 left today