Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 February 1996
- 1. The first question is from Mehdi Hasan Sahib, who has come from [place name unclear]; he does not wish to come forward himself: What is the greatest proof of the Oneness of Allah and of His existence?
- 2. Dr. Alamgir Sahib, a consultant cardiologist from Shepherd's Bush [originally from Lahore, Pakistan]: Nowadays there are many sects in which people declare that they are the true ones. First: if Mirza Sahib declared himself a prophet, how can that be confirmed? Anyone can stand up and say that, and five or six hundred thousand people can gather behind him, as you see in America and elsewhere that sects form like this. Second: when prophets came before, there was always some problem at the time which Allah had sent them to address. When he came, what problems were there that he had to declare himself a prophet? Why could he not do it otherwise?
- 3. Councillor Anand Patel from Newham, East London [originally from Maharashtra/Bombay]: Many people of your community live in our borough, and I have heard that they have endured many hardships and come here. Still, we do not get much information from them. I want to know why it is that, despite enduring oppression and abuse, you have not raised your voice to this day.
- 4. Mushtaq Ahmad Khan Sahib from Hendon: In Surah Al-Ahzab, verse [audio: 'forty-nine'?], it clearly states ‘Rasulallah wa Khatam-an-Nabiyyin’: Muhammad is not the father of any of your men, but the Messenger of Allah and the last Prophet. And in a hadith it is clearly stated: I am the last Prophet, you are the last Ummah; after me there is no new Prophet, nor any new Ummah. The question is: in view of these references and clear commandments, how can the claim of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib that he is a Prophet and Messenger, about whom a promise was made, be accepted as correct?
- 5. (The question is not included in this excerpt; the excerpt begins in the middle of the answer on the meaning of Khatam an-Nabiyyin and the continuation of prophethood.)
- 6. Were there prophecies in advance about every prophet as to when he would come, and also a specification of the geographical region in which he would appear? For example, the Gospel tells us that at the birth of Jesus, some people reached Bethlehem guided by a star. Is there any such prophecy about Hazrat Mirza Sahib as well that specifies the region of his advent? Also, please mention some of the signs of his truthfulness.
- 7. My question is: it is generally believed that when the Promised Messiah (as) comes, the Dajjal will also come at that time. The Dajjal will be one-eyed, his ears will be long, and generally one imagines some giant-like being or some kind of jinn. First explain this: where is that Dajjal? Where is he, and what was to happen with him? [Huzoor: And you also asked about the donkey, I was coming to that; time is short, come to the point quickly.] His donkey will be very big… [Huzoor: No, the next thing gives it away: it will feed on fire, is that not so?] Yes, exactly. That donkey will not eat fodder or grain. As in the stories, the vizier’s daughter ‘ate and ate only pumpkin’ – Punjabi tales have such things, she ate nothing but pumpkin – so this donkey will eat only fire and nothing else. Explain this too.
- 8. Huzoor, my question is long and needs explanation; if time is short I will not ask it. … Namely: the Holy Prophet (saw) was sent and spread Islam in a very beautiful manner, and his claim remained hidden in Mecca. That claim received strength when… [Huzoor: Hidden? Do you mean he made the claim secretly?] …subdued; the claim was not open at that time. [Huzoor: That is not correct, forgive me. The Holy Qur’an and the history of Islam refute this. His claim was proclaimed loudly; it reached every person in Mecca, there was not a single one for whom it was in any sense unclear. When the people of Mecca shut their doors on him after hearing the claim, he went out to the surrounding settlements and began conveying the same claim to others. That is correct. Now the next part of the question.] In any case, it received zeal, fervour and strength when an Islamic state… the sword was raised. [Huzoor: You may say that too…] I do not say it, people say it: when the foundation of an Islamic state was laid in Medina and a centre was formed…
- 9. My first question was an ordinary one; now comes the real one – brace yourself! [Huzoor: I am ready.] It is generally said that Allah the Exalted, the law He has made… Allah the Exalted is One, for the Holy Qur’an has presented Him as a unity so that no one may be like Him. [Huzoor: Allah, glorious is His majesty, is One in every respect. Fine, sit down.] My question is: it is generally said that Allah the Exalted acts according to the law of nature He has made, and this is not denied. Now: when Hazrat Jesus (as) was born, it is said of him that he was born without a father. After that some say he was hung on the cross and raised to heaven, and others say… The second is contrary to the law, so we do not accept it; the first is not contrary to God’s law, so we accept it. (How is that?)
10 of 10 left today