Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 May 1997
- 1. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. Abdul Aziz Khan from Peshawar, currently residing in Weingarten, Germany. Huzur, Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) wrote in his work Taryaq-ul-Qulub, page 350, in a footnote: “Let it be remembered that the Holy Prophet (saw) fixed two limits for his Ummah and said that the Ummah is safe from misguidance at whose beginning is my being and at whose end is the Promised Messiah. On one side the blessed being of the Holy Prophet (saw) is a protecting wall, and on the other side the blessed being of the Promised Messiah is an enemy-destroying wall. From this tradition it is clearly understood that the Holy Prophet (saw) did not consider as part of his Ummah those people who will come after the time of the Promised Messiah. And the time of the Promised Messiah extends as far as those who saw him, or those who saw them, or again those who saw those, are found in the world and remain established on his teaching. In short, the existence of three centuries (generations) is necessary in keeping with the way of prophethood. After that comes the end of virtue and purity…” [Huzur interrupts.] I only wanted to understand: the time Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) specified, and that people after that time will not be part of the Ummah Muhammadiyya – what did he mean to make us understand? Due to my lack of knowledge I could not understand it.
- 2. The Holy Qur’an states about Hazrat Solomon (as) that he ordered his nobles to bring the throne of the Queen of Sheba to him. What was the wisdom in this?
- 3. Second question: Huzur, Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) has stated that it is proven from the Holy Qur’an that Arabic is the mother of all languages. And it is also stated in the Holy Qur’an that Allah Himself taught man the knowledge of writing. Huzur, can we conclude from this that the Arabic script is also revealed, or…
- 4. My name is … My question is: today’s Bible has some correct things written in it to some extent, but where then is the correct Bible?
- 5. Assalamu alaikum, dear Huzur. My name is Usman Akram, I belong to the Heilbronn (?) branch of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. My question is about dreams: is it forbidden or permitted in Islam to want to know the interpretation of a dream from an elder?
- 6. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. My name is Yasir Mahmood, I am from the … branch of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. [Question not preserved in the audio; apparently: how should one introduce Ahmadiyyat to someone who knows nothing?]
- 7. One more question: is it true that the Bible has been changed?
- 8. Assalamu alaikum, my name is … My question is: when one says Hazrat Muhammad (saw), why must one additionally say “sallallahu alaihi wa sallam”?
- 9. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah. My name is Imtiaz Ahmad, from Majlis Heidelberg. Huzur, in our society there is the notion of the evil eye; people say someone has been struck by the evil eye. What is the reality of this?
- 10. [Beginning missing] … I was changing clothes and my eye fell on the picture; suddenly the thought came that the picture of Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) was in front of me. What did I do then? I immediately sought forgiveness (Istighfar), lest this become Shirk. This thought I…
- 11. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. This humble one’s name is Munawwar, Mubbashir (?) Bajwa. Huzur, my question is about the date of birth of the Holy Prophet (saw). In the history of Ahmadiyyat and elsewhere, historians give two dates: one 20 April 570 and one 24 April 571. Which is the correct date, and what is the viewpoint of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat on this?
- 12. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. Huzur, my name is Munir Ahmad Majoka, I belong to the Gross-Gerau branch of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. A question: Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) wrote at one place in Tafsir-e-Kabir that according to Islam marriage is possible even with a Hindu and a Jewish girl; and although this custom does not exist nowadays, if a Muslim man marries a Hindu girl or a Jewish girl, then in one and the same being on one side the Muslim calling it a grandson … [rest of the question not preserved in the audio]
- 13. Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. My name is Yasim (?) Rather, I belong to Majlis Gross-Gerau. My question is: scientists sometimes send messages into space so that we can find other creatures that possess knowledge and consciousness. My question is… [rest not preserved]
- 14. Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. [Name] from the … branch of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Huzur, my question is: there is wisdom in every act of Allah, but when a person falls ill – when small innocent children and adults are seen in such agonising illness that they die writhing in pain … And Huzur, some illnesses are caused by a person’s own carelessness, when he knows that a fatal illness can result from consuming those foods or things. Then is … [rest not preserved]
- 15. Huzur, my name is Nasir (?), from Frankfurt. Huzur, my question is: Allah has mentioned the creation of the heavens and the earth in many places in the Holy Qur’an, and there are many verses on this, such as Surah Al-A‘raf, Surah Bani Isra’il, etc., that Allah … [settled on the Throne]. Likewise Allah says in Surah …, verse 8 (?): It is Allah who created the heavens and the earth in six days, then He settled on the Throne, and His Throne is upon the water. My [question is what this means].
- 16. Assalamu [alaikum], Huzur. My [name is] Basharat Ahmad. I have a question: the Arabic verses on the Chola (robe) of Hazrat Baba Guru Nanak Sahib – were they given to him by God or did he write them with his own hand?
- 17. My question is: all people, the elders, say: do good deeds and you will go to Paradise. Will there also be sects like this in Paradise – Jews, Hindus, Islam, all?
- 18. [Child’s question, heavily fragmented:] … Pakistan is an Islamic country; there people say that they kill us … in Pakistan they say they are Muslims … why do you say we are different, why do you say they kill us … in Islam one is not allowed to kill …
- 19. My question is: why do you not hold such meetings in Pakistan?
- 20. My name is Aris (?). [Inaudible] Why does Allah take us when we are dead, and not alive?
- 21. [Beginning missing] ... then Hazrat Muslih Mau'ud (ra) (?) said: Fine, do go there for sightseeing, but do not pray at the tomb of Jahangir. I want to ask the reason for not praying.
- 22. [Fragmentary] Huzur, why do we wear this (head covering)?
- 23. My name is Waqar Ahmad, I belong to Majlis Nuremberg (?). A question has been on my mind for days: the so-called Khatm-e-Qur’an. People say that when someone has died, one should have the Holy Qur’an 'completed' for the reward (Isal-e-Sawab) of his soul – can a person finish the Holy Qur’an? Meaning, have the Holy Qur’an read so that reward reaches his soul. Or when someone has built a new house, they say first have the Holy Qur’an completed in it so that it is blessed. What is this?
- 24. Amir Abdul Azim (?). [Thanks for reading material.] Huzur, the Bible clearly states that the nations settled in Canaan, because they are idolaters, should be destroyed, even their children; there is a command to kill, and sometimes, according to the Bible, Allah even punished for not doing so. In the Holy Qur’an too, in Sura Al-Ma'ida: 'O my people, enter the holy land.' Some verses later: then two of those who feared Allah, on whom Allah had bestowed favour, said: 'Enter – in brackets in Tafsir-e-Saghir: attacking them and advancing against them – by this gate.' And a few verses later their reply: 'O Moses, go you and your Lord and fight them.' This also shows they were commanded to fight. Why, when they had never fought them before? They were in Sinai, those in Canaan. Also: the Holy Qur’an calls Canaan the holy land – has it called any other region so, and why this one?
- 25. My question is: why do we fold our hands when we pray?
- 26. My question: some say that Jesus (as) [gave?] this whole world ... Germany ... what has he given us, a gift ... Germany – the Germans say this, the Christians.
- 27. Another question. Huzur, on T-shirts there are these cartoon animals – is the prayer valid when wearing them?
- 28. My question: when we pray, is it permitted to get up [when the bell rings]?
- 29. My name is Qazi Wasim Ahmad, my Majlis is ... (?). My question: at the crucifixion of Hazrat Jesus (as) there was a severe earthquake and a storm. Did the Jews learn a lesson from this sign or not?
- 30. Huzur, my question is: Allah created this whole world – who created Allah?
- 31. My name is Muhammad Kamal. My question: when reading the Holy Qur’an, if one has read some and only a little remains, can one hold the Amin (completion ceremony) beforehand?
- 32. My name is Muhammad. My question was: why do we observe Ramadan, why do we fast?
- 33. My name is Munawar Ahmad, from Rachna Town, Pakistan; my father is Rahmat Ali Sahib. I lived ten, eleven years in Kassel, for six months now near Gross-Gerau. In childhood we learned the method of Tabligh from Chaudhry Ghulam Qadir Sahib, a Companion of the Promised Messiah (as) and Maulvi Fazil; Murabbi Barkatullah Mahmood Sahib or Aziz Shah Sahib, and the Amir Sahib himself used to come. My brothers and I adopted that method here. So I brought Germans when you came to Göttingen in 1995, one family, later four families to Schaffhausen (?), last year ... near Marburg (?). But Germans who, without training, [join] after one or two days or one or two months, come to a meeting and later say we do not like it. Which of these two methods is better? And a small second question about children: my daughter was in fifth grade; in Ramadan the teacher said today's period is only on fasting, Aisha will explain since we do not know – why, for what reason, and how. She explained everything. 20–25 other Ahmadi pupils study at that school. I wanted to request that the older pupils there be permitted to adopt such a method.
- 34. My name is Ata-ul-Momin. My question: my two sisters and I go to a school, and in the classes boys and girls are mixed. Sometimes the classes go away for three or four days – may we go along or not?
- 35. [Question missing, presumably: Why do we perform Hajj in Mecca?]
- 36. When performing Hajj, why is it done wearing white clothes?
- 37. [Question missing]
- 38. My question: why do we fast?
- 39. My question is ... why do we give Zakat? ... [unclear] ... Why can we not see Allah?
- 40. [Question largely missing, continuation on seeing Allah]
- 41. My question was: why can we not go to the cinema?
- 42. My name is Muhammad Noman, Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat ... (?). My question is: what is Nur (light)?
- 43. [Question missing, presumably on reincarnation]
- 44. (Question not recorded; end of an answer about the Hindu doctrine of reincarnation)
- 45. My name is Usman Hamid (?), my Majlis is … (unclear). My question is: is celebrating birthdays forbidden?
- 46. My name is Safir Ahmad, Majlis Weidsburg (?). I want to ask: we work with the right hand – with the left hand we do not eat (?) good things …
- 47. (Question partly inaudible) Maulvi Sahib, the grave of Hazrat Ali (ra) should be in Kufa?
- 48. My question is: Allah has 104 [names] – why? How many? 104?
- 49. I heard that chicken [products] contain pig fat. Is that true?
- 50. My name is Syed Nasim (?) Shah, I belong to Jabaltail (?) Leeheim (?); originally from Karachi. Huzur, in the Zuhr and Asr prayers we do not recite the Surahs aloud. Is there any wisdom in this?
- 51. My name is Mir Nasim Rashid (?), from Pakistan, Sialkot (?), from the Majlis … here. The Holy Qur’an [says] … that man should worship Him. My question is: what need did Allah have to be worshipped?
- 52. One more, light question. – Please go ahead. – (Question inaudible, apparently about the necktie)
- 53. (Partly inaudible) Where is that written? … I mean: was Hazrat Adam (as) the first human? I mean, were there prophets before him?
- 54. Now ask the question you want to ask. – Why did Allah not make Hazrat Muhammad (saw) the first prophet, so that Islam would begin right from the start?
- 55. My name is Rashid … (largely unintelligible) … [employers/people] force [someone] to eat pork and drink alcohol. He asks: what should I do?
- 56. My name is Munir. I want to ask: when I go to Allah and when someone of mine also goes there to Allah, will I be able to recognise him?
- 57. Dear Huzur, when Allah had bestowed so many favours on the Children of Israel, why then did these words come out of their mouths: 'Go thou and thy Lord and fight; we shall sit here' – you and your Lord go and fight the enemy, we are sitting right here?
- 58. My name is Iqbal Ahmad, I am Bangladeshi and belong to Iserlohn (?). [Conversation about Urdu/Bengali] Huzur, when Allah created Hazrat Adam (as) and created Mother Hawwa (Eve), He placed them in Paradise and said: live here in comfort. Then Allah said: you may not eat this wheat fruit. (Why then did they eat the wheat?)
- 59. Huzur, another question: Hazrat Jesus (as) was born without a father. What was Allah's purpose/wisdom in creating him without a father; why did He have him born so?
- 60. My name is Hamid Nauman Raja, I belong to Majlis Gowid-Mark (?). My question is: there are people who perform wazifas (recitation formulas) for something – so that our matter is accepted, to have a prayer answered. Is performing wazifas permissible or not? And if someone's matter gets fulfilled through a wazifa?
- 61. My name is Syed … (unclear). My question is: may we say 'ar-Rahman ar-Rahim' (Bismillah) before the Takbir? – Before which Takbir? – Before the Takbir of the prayer. – Saying it aloud?
10 of 10 left today