Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 August 1986
- 1. Hudhur, last month we were written (from the Tafsir / in a letter) that Ahmadi women should at least observe the 'Chinni Purdah'. We do not know what this is called and have never even seen it. What is this 'Chinni Purdah'?
- 2. Ashraf from Suriname. Hudhur, when women and men pray in the same mosque, there is a purdah (partition) in Rabwah and everywhere. In Suriname we have a big problem: the Sunnis do not let women into the mosque, but the Ghair-Mubai'in have removed the partition from the middle. How should this matter be resolved for us? Because all our Ahmadis have come from among them, and there are questions and discussions.
- 3. Abdul Ghafoor Chaudhry: With utmost respect I ask a question. When you arrive you say 'As-salamu alaikum wa rahmatullah' and you do not say 'wa barakatuhu'. What is the wisdom in this? Are there other prayers beyond 'barakatuhu', or do the prayers end with 'barakatuhu'?
- 4. Those from London are in front; they think the other questions are over and London has now begun. There is an article which compares the five prayers with court proceedings: Fajr corresponds to bringing the accused before the court, at Zuhr there is his examination (examination-in-chief), at Asr he is convicted, at Maghrib he is sentenced, at Isha the prison governor or officers take him to jail, and in the morning he is released. What does this mean?
- 5. A second question: a strong objection is raised against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat (…reference to Hazrat Syed Ahmad Barelvi Shaheed and another statement, including one of a 'Chaudhry Sahib'…) that the Holy Land (Palestine) will not be conquered by the sword. What does that mean?
- 6. The last question; the text is in English but I will translate it into Urdu: As we all know, the whole world is extremely restless and worried because the superpowers and major powers have not been able to reach any understanding on reducing nuclear weapons. The British Medical Association has warned the British government that in the event of nuclear war, in London the countless teaching and non-teaching hospitals, emergency services and fire brigades — all medical services — would be paralysed and crippled; and then the danger resulting from it of a sub-arctic (nuclear) winter. In 1932 Einstein wrote a letter to Freud (…). The question was whether it is in human nature to kill another, to beat and to harm. This was Einstein's question, and Freud said: yes, that is exactly so. Does the Holy Qur’an support the two of them?
- 7. (Question by Mian Ishtiaq(?) Sahib, not audible; apparently whether women may go to the graveyard or with the funeral procession.)
- 8. (The question is inaudible. From the answer it appears to concern women attending funerals and visiting graves, the questioner apparently saying the prohibition was not strict.)
- 9. (The question is largely unintelligible. It apparently concerns people in some place constantly occupied with contentious issues which one cannot get rid of – ‘you let go of the blanket but the blanket does not let go of you’.)
- 10. (Question inaudible. From the answer: why is the odd number preferred, e.g. in the rows of the funeral prayer, and is the funeral prayer valid if the number becomes even?)
- 11. Huzur, I wanted to ask: Huzur said about Bait-ul-Muqaddas (Jerusalem) that [the Jews] will one day have to leave from there. Can this mean that they will all accept the faith, that Israel from among them will believe …?
- 12. (Question only partly audible:) … Sunnah … In Arabia, where the Shafi‘i school predominates, [Bismillah] is recited aloud. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat … since it comes from the Hanafis …?
- 13. (Question fragmentary: in Africa children and families pray the Maliki way, that is how they learned it … Some people became Ahmadis because during Hajj in Mecca they [observed] … and declared there that the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is true because …)
- 14. … and another narration, in which Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi (rh) is also mentioned: that in the jihad he began he was outwardly not successful. It is a strange thing: at the same time that Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi began his work of reform and renewal, Hazrat Usman dan Fodio also began reform work in the region of Nigeria and in that connection also had to take up the sword. But the strange thing is that the jihad of Usman dan Fodio, the outward jihad by the sword, was very successful, so that from the region of Sokoto, where he arose, … (rest unintelligible)
- 15. For us it is the 15th … and the sacrifice took place on the 15th. Is it compulsory that only after their [Eid] prayer … as long as they have not prayed, the sacrifice cannot take place? For us it is the 15th, for them the 16th … that their prayer … and on the 15th the sacrifice took place …
- 16. I wanted to ask: if you are a guest somewhere and do not know … if you learn that it is a Khatam meal, so that you would get up and leave because you do not wish to accept it, but you have to stay because it concerns [e.g.] the parents – what should you do? Not eat that food, or stay sitting in the car, …?
10 of 10 left today