Urdu question-and-answer session, 5 April 1987
- 1. When I heard your Friday Sermon I received great spiritual strength, and sometimes tears come to the eyes when one thinks that one should send Durood upon the Prophet (saw) for his favours, love him and love Allah. When Huzur is before us, we certainly have these thoughts: that we should love the Prophet (saw) for his favours, love Allah and send Durood. But when you are not before us, we see nothing of this. So the proposal is that the Kalima, which is written at the side, be written in front, so that when you have left, the Kalima remains visible in front.
- 2. Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. I have two questions. The first: people use these stones, such as ruby or sapphire. In articles we read it is described that they have a great effect on people. What truth is there in this, Huzur?
- 3. Huzur, the second question: [Ghalib] says: ‘Loyalty with steadfastness is the essence of faith; if the Brahmin dies in the idol-temple, bury him in the Kaaba.’ Huzur, how far is this in accord with Islam? Whose view is this?
- 4. Huzur, at the gatherings, rallies and processions held against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, in order to gather more people or for other purposes, they say: if you come to these gatherings, the soul of the Holy Prophet (saw) will be comforted, and he will meet you very warmly on the Day of Judgement. And – God forbid – it is also said: if you kill (‘martyr’) an Ahmadi, the Holy Prophet (saw) will be very pleased with you on the Day of Judgement. Please shed some light on this.
- 5. In economics and the social system: a Muslim, whether living in Britain or Pakistan, pays income tax. In addition it is his religious duty to give charity and Zakat; that too is a form of tax. So why this double taxation, this burden on the person who [already] pays tax? [Follow-ups: If in Islam there is the concept of Bait-ul-Mal, would the concept of income tax end? And: so you mean Zakat should be adjusted according to indexation?]
- 6. My last question is about usury and interest. I have been thinking about it because of my business, and it also troubles my conscience: banks take the savings of X, Y and Z, three or four individuals, and pass them on to businessmen. To what extent is it permissible for us if, say, we take a bank loan of ten thousand pounds, do business with it, and the business flourishes?
- 7. [My name is] Ramesh – Abdullah. Assalamu alaikum. [Huzur asks about the name Ramesh; he explains:] Ramesh means that I was sent into the film world. ... I was also supposed to come for the meal at that time, but suddenly I received the doctor's report that I am ill, some diabetes ... [gap] ... many people know me here too ... [gap] ... I thought, instead of writing letters and getting answers – since you receive thousands of letters – there is little benefit; I thought that if I ever got the chance, I would speak myself. Today Allah has given me the chance to ask you something. Because I visit many people, some are Sunnis, some Hindus, Sikhs, here and there; they know me because I am from the film line and like to invite me. It is my habit to do a little Tabligh with them. Several people have ... [gap; apparently a question about resurrection in the same body and the location of Paradise and Hell].
- 8. (The question is not contained in the recording; the answer begins mid-sentence. From context, the questioner apparently wishes for the persecution to end and the era of victory to begin.)
- 9. My second question is: on average we are about five percent Ahmadis in our family, and about ninety percent are non-Ahmadis. When someone from our family dies, an elder, a brother, an uncle or anyone, we go along to the grave, where the funeral prayer is offered. When his funeral prayer takes place, we stand with our backs turned. Then the people who are in the majority say: you stand with your backs turned; you have been told to stand facing the other way. I ask Huzur: it is obligatory to honour and respect the deceased.
- 10. Assalamu alaikum. Huzur, kindly shed light on the following subject: freedom of conscience and freedom of expression of opinion and thought is a basic human right which Allah the Exalted has granted to man. But just as there are certain rules regarding every act – for example, a person, while carrying out the commandments of the Shariah, is bound not to do anything that creates disorder in the nation or country and violates the rights of the general public – please guide us as to what principles Allah has laid down regarding freedom of conscience, i.e. under which rules and regulations a person has freedom of conscience.
- 11. … If a Hindu dies, or a Sikh dies, or a Christian dies, and I am a friend of one of them – with Hindus and Sikhs the bier on which they carry the dead is called Arthi – may we carry those biers? Or do everything (equivalent) for Christians?
- 12. (Question not preserved.)
- 13. (Question unintelligible in the recording; it apparently concerns translating the Holy Qur’an.)
- 14. Huzur, in the Holy Qur’an twenty-seven or twenty-eight prophets are mentioned – twenty-five including … – some say twenty-four, but in my view twenty-five – whereas a hundred and twenty (twenty-four) thousand prophets came of whom the world does not know; has Allah told (about them)? … [gap] … this objection could be raised, that (only these) prophets are mentioned. The Holy Qur’an says that We have gathered in it all kinds of examples – fiha kutubun qayyima – We have gathered in it all living and lasting teachings; which means that out of these twenty-five prophets the Holy Qur’an selected those whose various aspects of life encompass the examples of every kind of prophethood. The rest may not be mentioned, but wherever you see prophets, their Sunnah will be within the circle of these twenty-five and not outside it. Therefore it is an extremely wise method to state the minimum necessary; otherwise, if it described each one separately, this book would not remain within man’s reach, it would exceed his capacity. Allah taught us the prayer: Ihdinas-siratal-mustaqim, in which there will be martyrs, the truthful, the righteous and prophets. Allah Himself taught this prayer; it is not that Allah only teaches a prayer and does not accept it. Just as not all earlier prophets are mentioned but only the paramount ones, will for the future too only paramount prophets be mentioned, and many prophets of whom the world does not know?
- 15. (Question unintelligible; from the answer it concerns the descent of man from apes, i.e. evolution.)
- 16. Assalamu alaikum. In the funeral prayer we offer for a believer – the coffin is placed in front or his name is in our mind – instead of praying for him we start praying for ourselves: Allahummaghfir li-hayyina wa mayyitina wa shahidina … – O Allah, forgive us all. We should pray for him, but we pray for ourselves. What is the reason for this?
- 17. … I read him (an author) on Islam. At one place, describing the time (of the Holy Prophet), he writes that the Jews had rebelled and as a result were taken captive. The Jews said: all right, our judge should decide our case. Then (the Holy Prophet) said: all right, bring your judge. When their judge was brought and the case presented to him, he ruled that three hundred and fifty Jews should be killed. Then (the Holy Prophet) said: all right, according to this judge’s ruling, these three hundred and fifty Jews shall be killed. He further argues: it is said that the Holy Prophet was very merciful, his rest of life is cited, he did this, he did that – although he could have forgiven them. Why did he not forgive them then? That was the question.
10 of 10 left today