Urdu question-and-answer session, 20 May 1995
- 1. Hudur, I have a question. The Islam which Allah, the Lord of Honour, conveyed through revelation to the Holy Prophet (saw) – we believe that the Holy Prophet (saw) passed on that very same Islam. The Islam that has reached us now did not reach us directly through the Holy Prophet (saw); it reached us through various intermediaries, among whom the noble Companions and the Tabi‘ and Tabi‘in played their part. If this Islam on which we walk today is the same one that the Messenger of Allah (saw) received from Allah the Exalted, then why are there differences in it? And if it is not …
- 2. (Asghar Mughal:) Assalamu alaikum. You have spoken in considerable detail. My only question is: you are a Muslim, I am a Muslim, all these people sitting here are Muslims, alhamdulillah, they recite the Kalima. Fine. So what yardstick do we have by which, about a person who recites the Kalima, I or someone else or a third person may say that he is a kafir? And if someone has such a yardstick, what is its basis? Is it political, or is it simply a matter of inventing some catchword to humiliate the other? If so, then it is wrong. If not, then why does it happen? Respectfully.
- 3. (Khalil Sahib from Mirpur, Azad Kashmir, residing in Birmingham:) Hudur, the question is: we have never heard of any government declaring a religious sect a minority or non-Muslim. I think that in Pakistan Ahmadi Muslims were declared non-Muslim because Ahmadi Muslims are educated and, through service to humanity, can prove beneficial to the Pakistani people. Therefore domestic and foreign governments do not want Ahmadi Muslims to be able to do this work. Is my view correct, or is there some other reason?
- 4. Your Excellency Mirza Tahir Ahmad, the question I am going to ask you today concerns Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian. Between 1849 and [18]44 [unclear], when he made his prophecies, people were very displeased. In 1889 he founded the community of Allah. [Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh) adds: At that time he had not yet claimed to be the Messiah. The claim of Messiahship and prophethood came later, in 1891 and at the beginning of 1901. But the claim of being divinely commissioned, i.e. the Imam Mahdi, and the founding of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat happened together.] So my question is mostly about his prophecies. My second question concerns the prophecies of Jesus Christ in the Holy Bible, made by Hazrat Isa (as). Thirdly, Dr. K. L. Nasir of Gujranwala wrote a book in 1960, “Haqiqat-e-Mirza”, in which he raised the question that Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian said that his marriage would take place with Muhammadi Begum, and it did not. So was his prophethood proven false? [Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh): I will inshallah answer each question one by one. As for K. L. Nasir: long before him, in the very time of the Promised Messiah (as), Muslim scholars had raised this point a lot. Nasir only copied the Muslim scholars and presented nothing of his own. Since you have probably read only his literature, your mind went to Nasir. All the objections Nasir collected against the Promised Messiah (as) are indebted to the efforts of those scholars who from the very beginning of his claim launched a character assassination campaign. At first they engaged in a debate of arguments, but very soon abandoned it and adopted character assassination. The same continues today. I will answer that later; first ask your first question.] The question is: all the prophecies that Hazrat Isa (as), Jesus Christ, made concerning Jerusalem, and, as you told me in the earlier question, that he would go to the lost tribes, were all fulfilled. So why were the prophecies of Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian not fulfilled? And if they were fulfilled, which ones were they?
- 5. By the way, I have a book for you to read, a very good book, “Facts to Fiction”. So you are explaining to me that the prophecies of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian are being fulfilled continuously even today? [Yes, that is right.] And some prophecies have not yet been fulfilled? [Not yet, correct.] But the matter of Muhammadi Begum, the third – that was not fulfilled?
- 6. A friend who does not wish to reveal his name asks: Is the Kalima of the Ahmadis different from that of other Muslims?
- 7. Question from the ladies: We do believe that Hazrat Khalifatul Masih IV (rh) is the Khalifa of Allah. After that, is it necessary to enter the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat by taking the Bai’at of the Promised Messiah (as)?
- 8. Assalamu alaikum. Respected Sir, on what grounds have the followers of this community of Ahmadiyyat been declared disbelievers in Pakistan? This is today’s situation and known to all. Before that, it has been narrated to me that around the time of my birth or shortly before, your emissaries went to Afghanistan and the government of Afghanistan already issued this fatwa, declared them disbelievers and had them executed – you must know this. In this light: why did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib not content himself with calling himself a Mujaddid, Muhaddith or Imam of the age, as other revered Imams have been and still are – the example of Imam Khomeini is before you – and why did he claim to be the Promised Messiah or the Mahdi? In the Hadith there are countless narrations that the Promised Messiah will come, will be lowered at the minaret of the Kaaba, will kill the Dajjal of that time at a place [Ludd?], will establish his rule for a period and will dispense justice. You and Mirza Sahib have also explained justice, but all these narrations do not agree with the Hadith. Regarding the Mahdi, narrations say he will be from the family of the Messenger, and many Shias call him the hidden Imam who will appear.
- 9. (Continuation of an answer already in progress; the question itself is not contained in this excerpt. From context it concerns the coming of the Imam Mahdi and the Messiah, whether he must come from the Ahl-e-Bait, and how the prophecies about the Dajjal are to be understood.)
- 10. With respect I would like to note: as far as I have studied Mishkat Sharif or Bukhari Sharif, the condition of the Dajjal as you have explained it has not come to my knowledge. What has, though, is that he will be of mighty build, will supposedly go round the whole world in forty days, on one side of him there will be paradise and on the other hell, he will cut a man apart, then bring him back to life, then try to cut him again and will not be able to. [Later:] That was not my point; my point was that in the two hadith collections I have read, Bukhari Sharif and Mishkat Sharif, this incident is not described this way; perhaps there is another book from which you have studied it.
- 11. According to that verse of the Holy Qur’an which comes concerning Jesus (as), ‘rafa’a ila as-samawat’ [he was raised to the heavens] – from this… I would like to submit something respectfully.
- 12. Just for one point, a last small matter – this is important. As found in narrations, the Holy Prophet (saw) went on the Mi’raj, and it is a very long story: he met Moses (as), and Moses asked him: O Messenger of Allah, how will this be? Our Ummah turned away even in our time, and in your time – you are the Seal of the Prophets, and until the Day of Judgement… [When asked:] I did not read it in a hadith but in a narration. I only want a short answer: you [the Prophet (saw)] summoned the spirit of Imam Ghazali (rh)…
- 13. In the same way, in the Psalms (Zabur) and in the Bible the advent of the Holy Prophet (saw) is mentioned explicitly by name, by the name Ahmad. But in the Holy Qur’an nothing about him comes with such a name, and when anyone calls us ‘Mohammedan’ we refute it: ‘We are not Mohammedans, we are Muslims, our religion is Islam.’ So why is the word ‘Ahmadiyyat’ used among you, [which] the Promised Messiah (as)…
- 14. Huzur, the question [of Mohsin Khan Sahib] is: why are all Muslim sects united against the Ahmadis? What is the reason for this?
- 15. Huzur, the second question of Mohsin Khan Sahib is: why, in addition, has the Saudi government banned Ahmadis from performing Hajj?
10 of 10 left today