Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 February 1997
- 1. All Muslims believe that Hazrat Jesus (as) is alive in heaven and in his place ... The Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat says that he died and that his tomb is in Kashmir. What is the proof that his tomb is in Kashmir?
- 2. Most people believe in the existence of jinn and ghosts. What is Huzur's position on this?
- 3. (Question in Punjabi, poorly audible) I am Harchan Singh ... Guru Baba Nanak went to Mecca ... What is your view on this?
- 4. Huzur, in your view what are the conditions by adopting which unity can come about in the Muslim Ummah?
- 5. May I ask you in English? (Huzur: Ask; I will also translate it and answer in Urdu.) ... in the month of Ramadan ... the Surah ..., the verse: 'O ye who believe, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those who are in authority among you ...' (rest of the question unintelligible)
- 6. (After personal words of thanks: a mountain of grief had fallen upon me, I asked Huzur for prayers at ten at night, and the result is miraculous; not only my face but my heart too is cheerful, Alhamdulillah.) Huzur, I am in great difficulty. God is the Ruler, Wise, All-Knowing and Everlasting. In the Holy Qur’an and according to the general belief of Muslims, man has been a monotheist since the beginning of creation, and since Allah made humans human He created the means of their guidance. But all archaeological research to date has clearly shown that early man was not a monotheist but a polytheist. This is a contradiction for which I seek a solution.
- 7. Is having true dreams often a proof that a person is truthful? How do true dreams differ from divine revelation?
- 8. The point is this: I am a Muslim, but not an Ahmadi. That does not mean I am against Ahmadis; everyone has their own belief. I have two questions. The first is very simple: what is basically the difference between the Ahmadi sect and the group that is not Ahmadi? If there is a difference, two communities have formed. The second question: we offer the prayer and you also offer it. Is there any difference between your prayer and ours? In other words, have you made any amendment or addition to the surahs we recite?
- 9. One more thing: what is your concept regarding prophethood? A simple example: when he had died, had prophethood ended?
- 10. (Second question:) Is there any change in your prayer? Someone had said that perhaps you had made a slight amendment to incorporate your concept in it.
- 11. [Mr Raju, councillor in Kingston, Hindu, family from India via Kenya.] My question is: in the Holy Qur’an, the Gita, the Bible, the New Testament – whenever a great person was born, he was floated away from small villages down a river to be saved in another village, and behind that small children were killed with poison. I have seen this connection in two or three such books. What is the reason behind this connection?
- 12. [Mr Sibghatullah Qadri, barrister and Queen's Counsel.] I came here to learn; asking a question was not my aim. But on the young man's question about the Ahmadi difference, you said very cogently that the other mullahs say a prophet will not come but an old prophet can come by the back door, and you say he can come by the front door. Conditions in the world are changing very fast, technology is changing, perhaps there may even be new life several times. In your view can another prophet come, is there a need for it? In my view, human opinion has no bearing on whether a prophet comes or not. The question should be: if Mirza Sahib is an Ummati prophet, as you say, is there any indication about him in the Holy Qur’an and Hadith? And if there is, is the possibility of another prophet also open?
- 13. [Question from the ladies:] Is it possible for a sinful person to become righteous? What actions are necessary for this?
- 14. [Dr Iftikhar Ahmad, Los Angeles.] I had been thinking of asking this for a long time. In the book of the Promised Messiah (as), ‘The Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam’, in mentioning nutfa – about which I have no clarification – in the definition of nutfa it is mostly likened to sperm. I want to know from reference in the Holy Qur’an whether nutfa refers to the embryo or only to sperm.
- 15. [From the ladies:] If Allah the Exalted can create Jesus (as) without a father, then He can also raise him to heaven.
10 of 10 left today