Urdu question-and-answer session, 3 December 1995
- 1. Sir, my question is: from the time of the Messenger (saw) up to the Rightly Guided Caliphs, which sect was Islam? Different ones have arisen; it did not remain one. – Clarification: From the time of the Rightly Guided Caliphs until now, or up to the time of the Rightly Guided Caliphs? – Up to that time, you are saying? I had misunderstood. – There was only one Islam; there was no sect at all. – There was no sect at all. Then how did these come about now?
- 2. Hudhur, first I want to offer you my salam. I have learned that Hazrat Isa (as) is buried in Kashmir; I just wanted to find out how he got there – number one. And my second question, Hudhur: for the raising up of Hazrat Isa (as) the word raf‘ is used in the Holy Qur’an. Does it mean an elevation of rank, or was he actually raised to heaven? And the third question is… (Hudhur: Let us first resolve these two.) I thought I would ask three questions and go. (Hudhur: My wish is that you remain standing here so that we talk face to face.)
- 3. Hudhur, if you permit, the third one. (Hudhur: The third too, certainly.) I will not name those respected personalities so that no one is hurt. But regarding Hazrat Maryam (as) it is mentioned that among the women of all the worlds she has the highest rank. So is her rank higher even than those women – the pure wives (of the Prophet saw), or the daughter, etc.?
- 4. According to Ahmadi belief, the door – the chain – of prophethood has not been closed. Will the prophets who come in the future also be entitled to call themselves Mahdi?
- 5. Hudhur, my second (question): I have seen and heard some of your recent Friday sermons. There are one or two points in them on which I would like clarification. (Hudhur: You listen to the sermons? Good, then go ahead. It is a scholarly discussion. There is a possibility that – since this series too is not closed – many points are yet to open up. If you now mention some points for the sake of understanding, everyone will benefit; I will include them in a future sermon.) In one sermon – in fact I think it extended over two – on ‘Nurun ‘ala Nur’ (light upon light), your discussion was very scholarly and to a large extent scientific too. In it you said that light has a hidden form and a manifest form, and the hidden form is sometimes more powerful, and you gave the example of black holes: they are not visible, but if something goes near them, they pull it with tremendous force. My point is that black holes, if one looks at them, are dead stars – a star that has ended its life and died; there is no light in them. – Secondly: on another Friday you said: ‘The heart of the believing servant is the Throne of the Lord (Arsh-e-Maula).’ My submission is: the believing servant is a descendant of Adam – where was the Throne of the Lord before the creation of Adam?
- 6. Hudhur, the question is: the Muslim Ummah today is divided into countless sects. Those whose coming was prophesied have also come – that is, those who were to unite the Muslim Ummah again have come and also gone. Yet the sects have not ended. When will they be united – is it even possible?
- 7. My question was, Hudhur: Hazrat Chaudhry Zafrullah Khan Sahib helped the Arabs a great deal in obtaining their rights, and in particular he was also Pakistan's first Ahmadi foreign minister. Why did he not help the Kashmiris of today? (garbled, incomplete)
- 8. (Continuation of an earlier question about Kashmir and Chaudhry Sir Muhammad Zafrullah Khan (ra); its beginning precedes this section.)
- 9. Hudhur, I wanted to ask: in Pakistan allegations are made against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, and especially against you, that you are not a well-wisher of Pakistan. What would you say about this?
- 10. (Inder Singh Uppal MBE) There is a conflict in my mind which I would like you to try to remove. It concerns a personal experience: some years ago I persuaded a local authority that there should be a community centre here where Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims would have facilities for prayer. With great effort the community centre was built. At its inauguration we decided to invite radio and television, and that all three of our religions – Hindu, Muslim, Sikh – should pray there. I invited everyone, including the Ahmadiyya Association. The Hindu festival went well; there were facilities for ablution and for the Hindus their holy night. I asked that the Ahmadi brother also give the Adhan. There were many Muslims, and there was a very strong protest. (Hudhur: Who protested?) The Muslim community, against the Ahmadi giving the Adhan. My situation became very bad. I said: the Ahmadis are Muslims too; let them give the Adhan, and you give it too. Both were recorded; both gave the Adhan. My misfortune was that when the programme came on television, the Adhan given by the Ahmadi [rest unclear], and they have not forgiven me to this day. That was twenty years ago. I have two requests: first, why did they protest so strongly? They are against me to this day, but I respect them. Second, in the twentieth century can there be no resolution to remove the conflict – can't we live like brothers? Third: is there any unanimity between the Hindu and Sikh religions and Islam?
- 11. (Rehan Ali, Norbury) Just now you were explaining words of one verse by words of another verse. The question is: who were the explainers? Since the Holy Qur’an came in Arabic words, in the Arabic language, explanations are needed for us later; this is the greatest difficulty we feel. Whether Ibn Abbas (ra), Aisha (ra) or Imam Abu Hanifa gives the explanation, the original source must be verified. The explanation and exegesis of the Holy Qur’an comes from the Hadith. Imam Makhul is quoted as saying the Holy Qur’an is more dependent on the Sunnah than the Sunnah on the Holy Qur’an. So one has to go directly to the Hadith, because when Allah sent down the Holy Qur’an there had to be someone to explain it in clear words – and for this the Holy Prophet (saw) was present. … I only want to remove one doubt in my heart: the verse in Surah Al-Ahzab in which Allah says He made the Holy Prophet (saw) Khatam-un-Nabiyyin and that he has no son – and the Hadith fully confirm this verse. Some hadith reach only one level, but this one has reached the level of mutawatir. (Later:) Hadith have various grades – weak, marfu', etc. (Later:) Allah commanded: pray, fast, perform Hajj, give Zakat, but did not explain all these in detail; for this we depend on the Sunnah. (Later:) Then Allah should have sent down only the Holy Qur’an and ended prophethood?
- 12. (Syed Nisar Ali Rizvi, Chawinda) First of all I give thanks for the honour of seeing you for the first time. I am visiting here and came through Dr. Zafar Sahib, who said that I would be very impressed by this purposeful gathering. In Pakistan Chawinda is called 'Rabwah number two'; there are many Ahmadis there. My first question was: what is your difference from other schools of thought on the issue of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (finality of prophethood)? Your Imam has explained something about this, and you too have said something, so I will not stress it much. My second question: Muslims, whether living in Islamic countries or non-Islamic countries, in Europe or elsewhere, in my observation are in their majority – not all – victims of hypocrisy, and often Muslims are called terrorists and fundamentalists. Have you or your Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat made any plan for this problem, what is being done?
- 13. (The question is not contained in the excerpt; from the answer it is evident that it concerned the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat’s understanding of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (the Seal of Prophethood).)
- 14. What was your next question? – The second question was: people, mostly the majority, use Islam with hypocrisy (?), and that is wrong. Other people therefore think badly of us, call us terrorists, or say we are fundamentalists, and this does no service to Islam. Since yours is an organised community, you must have made a plan for this problem – it is a big problem.
10 of 10 left today