Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 July 1995
- 1. I intended to ask a question. For many years I have been in great perplexity and to this day I have not received a satisfying answer. What shall I do? Huzur is a source of understanding and insight. It concerns 'mā malakat aimānukum' (those whom your right hands possess). There are verses about this in several places in the Holy Qur’an. By my own understanding I have not been able to find a satisfying interpretation or explanation. I request Huzur to shed light on this issue.
- 2. However, some supplementary questions arise. [Huzur: Ask them now, or leave them for later, as you wish.] The question that arises is: slavery is itself such an institution that, if it is given permanence …
- 3. Why is it necessary to accept the Imam Mahdi?
- 4. (Submitted in writing) Other groups in Pakistan, such as the Shias, were not declared a minority. Why was the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat declared a minority, what are the reasons? Why were equal rights not given to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in Pakistan?
- 5. (The questioner comes from a family whose father had joined the Lahore Ahmadis, and is pledging allegiance today.) Hazrat Maulvi Muhammad Ali Sahib and Hazrat Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din Sahib were among the Companions and rendered great services, but they separated from Khilafat. What were the reasons that deprived them of Khilafat? And can the Lahore Ahmadis (Ahl-e-Paigham) be brought back under the umbrella of Khilafat, and how?
- 6. [The question is not included in this excerpt; this is the continuation of an answer about the split after the election of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) and why many followed the Lahoris.]
- 7. [Question barely audible; in essence: Can the Lahoris/Paighamis be brought back collectively into the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat on the basis of an agreement?]
- 8. [After introduction: Muhammad Ratish(?) Sahib, not an Ahmadi, attending for the first time.] Your Honour, I watched a video cassette of yours; a friend of mine, who is an Ahmadi, showed it to me. In it you said that the Holy Qur’an states that Hazrat Noah (as) lived nine hundred and fifty years, but human reason does not accept this. [Huzur: Did I say that?] Yes, you said that his natural age was not nine hundred and fifty years, but his Shariah age was nine hundred and fifty years. Do you have any proof for this from the Holy Qur’an? The Holy Qur’an is a complete book; you yourself say we cannot shift even a zer or zabar in it. If we cannot do that, then … You further said: if Hazrat Noah lived nine hundred and fifty years, why did he not meet Hazrat Abraham (as), who came nine hundred years after him? And you said no historian has written that Hazrat Noah and Hazrat Abraham met each other. Is it right that we believe a historian when our Holy Qur’an tells us something?
- 9. [Dr. Ansar Sahib:] My questions may perhaps appear somewhat blasphemous or apostatic, but I saw your remarks about Rushdie, so that encouraged me. In the Holy Qur’an it says: “Walladhina jahadu fina la-nahdiyannahum subulana”. This shows its linguistic beauty: “fina” – Allah is speaking in majestic language, and it is about depth. [After being told his voice was unclear, he repeated:] The meaning of the verse: Allah says that if you search in Our exalted Being, seek, go into Our depths, then We will show you new and newer paths. From this and from the practical visibility of the time or the world, you will see: it is Sunnat Allah – evolution, progress, change. Then what ordinary Muslims say, “akmaltu lakum dinakum”, takes on an esoteric, hidden meaning, that it is a drama, a game, idle pastime …
- 10. [Questioner, not an Ahmadi:] … from my father’s side, from my mother’s side – my sympathies are with the Ahmadis, since my mother was an Ahmadi. I have always fought for the Ahmadis, but I am not an Ahmadi. Wherever it is said that Ahmadis are disbelievers, or that this or that happens in Rabwah, I have to defend them, because I know the Ahmadis closely, for my mother’s sake. Apart from that I have seen Ahmadis closely and found nothing wrong for which I would have turned away. I saw my mother at home and my relatives. [Huzur: If you found nothing wrong, why did you turn away?] I did not turn away from them; I consider myself a Muslim, because my relatives include Ahmadis, Shias and Sunnis, and I have seen them all closely. The issue that has arisen is that for some time I have also been going to Friday prayers, and I have found nothing wrong among the Ahmadis that would make me afraid. [Huzur: Someone who sees all sects closely comes to know who is wrong … There you found wrong, here you did not …] I am trying to get there now. [Huzur: The noble verse will help you: strive sincerely, pray, and perhaps the goodness that was in your heart from the start, that you kept supporting despite opposition, will help you. Allah rewards in this way too.] Recently I went to Pakistan. My cousin, whose mother was also an Ahmadi, has joined the Tablighi Jamaat. Whoever goes to his house is preached to: become a Muslim, pray regularly, put your deeds right. I told him that now I mostly offer Friday prayers with the Ahmadis. He said: you are becoming an apostate, you are going astray. I said: I don’t know whether they are wrong or right, but I know one thing: the things they say are not wrong things; they don’t say steal or rob. I have found nothing wrong in what they say that would make me say these people are wrong; so in my view they are fine. He went and got a book, leafed through it a great deal, picked out passages and said: when you go back, ask them this question. I said: fine, I think it’s no problem, I will ask them. I don’t remember the book exactly. In it was written – he said it was a book by Mirza Sahib, quite a thick one – that Allah made him Mary and he was born from his own belly. [Huzur: That is not what is written.] Well, born from his own belly – that is what I read there.
- 11. A small question about Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as): how and where did he learn these languages – Persian, Arabic, Urdu etc.?
- 12. Hazrat Sahib and friends, before coming here I did not know the full purpose of my coming. But when I learned that I would be able to have darshan of Hazrat Sahib and have the chance to hear him, I said: this I will never miss; what greater good fortune could there be? Thank you very much. If permitted, I will speak in Punjabi. [Hazrat Sahib (rh): You speak Urdu so well.] Yes, I know a little Urdu. [Hazrat Sahib (rh): I am enjoying it; you speak very well.] Then, when I was told there would also be a chance for questions and answers, I felt: what could I ask? We are so close to one another that a question would be like asking myself, and the answer like asking myself too. Still, it is when closeness is great that the courage to ask arises. Sitting here, the thought came that the chance to meet a personality we call divine (rabbani) comes very rarely in life and only by great fortune, so I should surely seek some direction from you – not only for myself. True, you are addressing an Islamic gathering, but your relationship is with everyone, with the whole world. When I think this way: although today there is no First or Second World War, the state of the world is very grave and looks very dangerous. And it has happened again and again in history that whenever the course of the world, the course of history, was turned in very difficult and dangerous circumstances, it was the struggle and sacrifices of minority communities that turned it. The last Russian president, Gorbachev, particularly acknowledged this and acted upon it. So it kept coming to my mind to request you: in which direction are today's conditions heading, and how can deliverance from this danger be attained? For this I ask you for direction.
10 of 10 left today