Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991
- 1. The first question I would like to put in this session is this: the government here gives a children's allowance for the children, and it comes in the mother's name … This problem was also discussed in our Majlis-e-Shura.
- 2. The second question is: Hazrat Jonah (as) prayed: “La ilaha illa Anta, Subhanaka, inni kuntu minaz-zalimin” (There is no god but You, holy are You, I was indeed among the wrongdoers). On the basis of this prayer Parwezi Sahib says that Hazrat Jonah was a wrongdoer (zalim), because he himself admitted that he was one. How can a prophet be a wrongdoer? That is my question.
- 3. My third question is: what is described in the Holy Qur’an about Hazrat Joseph (as), the whole story – there is something in it I do not understand. On the one hand Hazrat Joseph sees a dream and presents it to Hazrat Jacob (as), relates it. On the other hand his brothers take him away and throw him into the well. I only want to ask: how old was Hazrat Joseph (as) at that time?
- 4. The fourth question: the Holy Qur’an mentions seven earths and seven heavens. What is meant by this?
- 5. Hazrat, I request permission to ask three questions. First question: in his last Friday sermon Huzur said that regarding the sign given to Hazrat Jonah (as) – where it is said he stayed three days and three nights in the belly of the fish – the time he actually spent in the belly of the fish was no more than two or three hours. This explanation agrees with what we believe about Hazrat Jesus (as), that he remained on the cross no more than two or three hours and spent the rest in unconsciousness and suffering. But it is said that Hazrat Jesus (as) was given only one sign, no sign other than that of the Prophet Jonah … [Huzur: No, Jesus (as) told certain opponents who demanded a sign that they would be given no sign except this; Jesus had countless signs. What does this have to do with your subject? Please explain.] The connection is: in the same sermon Huzur said that our Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat repeatedly says it was three days and three nights. How do we reconcile that with Huzur's new explanation?
- 6. Second question: in his last Friday sermon Huzur said that the incident in which Hazrat Buddha (as) left his wife and child … [Huzur: Hazrat Job or Hazrat Buddha? – Hazrat Gautama Buddha.] … that his leaving for the forest abandoning his wife and child is far removed even from basic morality.
- 7. I wish to present the third question to Huzur: when Huzur looked at our programme for Norway, Huzur instructed us that the times we write should not be given after twelve o'clock as 13 or 14 hours but in the Pakistani way … But among the Norwegians it is customary that, if a time is given to them on Norwegian paper, it is given as 13 or 14 hours. If we want to tell the Norwegians, we have no alternative word to tell them. After that came the instruction that we should do it this way in future.
- 8. I would like to ask two questions. First question: in Islam the eating of certain things is forbidden, and not eating them has physical benefits besides spiritual ones. I would like to ask: according to modern science, what kind of benefits are there in not eating pork? [Huzur: You have made a statement; support it. You have not asked a question. You said that besides spiritual benefits there are also physical benefits of not eating it – tell me what they are.] That is exactly what I want to ask you.
- 9. The second question: in our Pakistani society it is assumed that those who call themselves Sayyid may be from the lineage of the Holy Prophet (saw). What is the real meaning of Sayyid?
- 10. The question concerns the environment and society here: if we have no job, we receive unemployment allowance. The question is: if we deliberately do not want to work, will that income be lawful (halal)? And together with this another … [Follow-up: if someone is offered taxable work and does not take it …]
- 11. Hazrat, secondly: a Maulana has been after me for a long time. He says he is quite poor and that he has to perform Hajj but cannot.
- 12. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah. Huzur, my question concerns the present politics of Pakistan, the phase it is going through. After the defeat of Iraq you said in sermons about Iraq that these conditions can befall any Muslim country. [Huzur: Right; in fact they will come in turn.] After the defeat of Iraq, George Bush declared that he would give the world a new world order. And according to current news, America has prepared a formula for an independent Kashmir under which it will join neither India nor Pakistan. [Huzur: Who told you? From which news?] From Pakistani news, the newspaper Jang; Mahmood Sham, a columnist, wrote it. He reasoned that America no longer needs Pakistan since the Geneva Accord. Because of enmity towards Muslims it seems that similar conditions will befall Pakistan. Supposing America really is preparing such a formula and Pakistan does not accept it – what conditions could Pakistan face?
- 13. Huzur, I would like to ask three questions. The first is: Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh) said in a sermon that before half of the fifteenth century [Hijri] has passed, signs of unity will appear in the Muslim Umma. [Huzur: When did he say it?] Probably in 1969 or 1970. I wanted to ask whether, according to certain prophecies, any specific time has been fixed for this.
- 14. The second question is: now that changes are taking place in Russia after the fall of the Berlin Wall [Huzur: The wall fell after the changes], will the Muslim nations accordingly turn rapidly towards Ahmadiyyat, or is it more likely that the united Russia will accept Islam?
- 15. Huzur, I wanted to ask: in our prophecies in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, or in the books of the Promised Messiah (as), we read that hardly any people will remain in the world who do not accept him. In particular he said that Muslims would accept him very soon. How is this to be understood?
- 16. No, Huzur, I wanted to ask: there are the Arab nations and the Russians among whom there are Muslims. I understood that God grants ability to whomever He wills. But is there anything in the prophecies saying that the Arab nation will be granted it first, or the Russians?
- 17. Another question, also about Russia: regarding the current changes in Russia, the Western or world media generally say that Western Europe will benefit greatly, especially financially.
- 19. When a child is born, is its lifespan decided at the time of birth? Who decides – Allah decides at what age this child will die. Why does He decide so? … It is about knowledge.
- 20. As you just said: sometimes He wants something to happen. For example, a man does wrong, say against Islam, and his end comes: another man quarrels with him over something and kills him. Actually Allah decided that his life be ended. Is the man through whom this happened, in which Allah's will was involved, also guilty?
- 21. Sir, when so many poor children are born in Ethiopia and die of hunger – is their birth and what you just spoke of also linked to Allah …?
- 22. One more question for information, for everyone: when we offer prayer in congregation and a mistake occurs – the Imam does only one prostration, we follow behind, the Imam doesn't remember, but someone in the row behind realises the Imam did one prostration and forgot the second. After he has said the Salam, he is told from behind: you did only one prostration. Can everyone then do the prostration, or after the Salam is nothing possible?
- 23. My question is also about prayer. Islam says that a traveller, or one who is to stay somewhere for a few days, should shorten the prayer, pray half. I want to ask: what wisdom is in this, why is the prayer shortened?
- 24. My question concerns Witr. One says Salam after two Rak'at and then prays the third Rak'a and says Salam again. But if after two Rak'at someone talks to somebody or changes his place and goes elsewhere, will these two Rak'at count, or will he have to pray all three at one time?
- 25. The question is: God says, I cover your sins, so you cover people's sins. Where in the Holy Qur’an has God said this, that He covers faults?
- 26. A person is thoroughly good, he does not lie and serves humanity, but does not associate himself with any religion. Are his deeds accepted in the sight of God Almighty or not? Should he adopt a religion or not?
- 27. Second question: Huzur's sermons have been going on for some time about those who received favours (In’am-yafta) … (Huzur: those have ended.) In them Hazrat Moses (as) and his brother were mentioned: why did he petition Allah about his brother: O God, entrust this responsibility to my brother, do not entrust it to me? After that he also expressed a weakness of his – what was that weakness, and who was that man who by his hand …?
10 of 10 left today